Affiliation(s)
1. Soil and Water Management Laboratory, Department of Natural Resources and Environment, Hassan II Institute of Agronomy & Veterinary Medicine, Rabat 10101, Morocco
2. Applied Science and Technology, North Carolina Agricultural and Technical State University, Greensboro, NC 27411, USA
ABSTRACT
Water resources face many pressures and stresses around the world.
Assessing the vulnerability of water resources is, therefore, increasingly an
essential practice in water resources management. Several studies of water
resources vulnerability have been carried out around the world during the last
three decades. Thus, the main objective of this study was to analyze water resources vulnerability
assessment tools and identify the methodological trend of water resources
vulnerability assessment at the local level in existing literature. To achieve
this objective, the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and
Meta-Analyses (PRISMA) method has been applied to include or exclude articles.
Articles on water vulnerability numbering 374 were preselected in the
ScienceDirect and the Google Scholar databases. Only 32 out of the 374 articles
met the inclusion criteria defined for the analysis. The results show that
China (21.9%), U.S.A. (9.4%) and Canada (6.3%) are the most active countries
publishing water resources vulnerability assessments. Some 191 vulnerability
indicators from the 32 articles were classified into five categories of
factors: physical factors (33.5%), socio-economic factors (28.3%),
environmental or eco-environmental factors (25.1%), institutions and governance
factors (7.3%) and infrastructure factors (5.8%). This study shows that almost
half of the studies (47%) considered all five categories of factors, 9.4%
considered four categories of factors, 6.3% considered three categories of
factors, 28% used two types of factors and 9.4% considered only one category.
Researchers have used several methods to assess water resources vulnerability: overlay
and index methods (59.4%), process-based models (12.5%), statistical methods
(9.4%), overlay and index methods plus process-based model (9.4%), overlay and
index methods plus statistical methods (6.3%) and statistical methods plus
process-based models (3.1%). Geographic information system (GIS) is an important tool
in assessing the vulnerability of water resources with almost 60% of the
studies using it at some stage of the assessment. In recent years, there is an
increasing trend toward conceptualizing the vulnerability of water resources in
a holistic way.
KEYWORDS
Water vulnerability, water resources management, water vulnerability
assessment tools.
Cite this paper
References